05 January 2012

The Best Movie Adaptation from a Children’s Book

The Salon article on good and bad cinematic adaptations of children’s books (quoted here and here) got me thinking about my own list.

To judge simply by the artistic distance from the written source to the cinematic reworking, my top choice is The Black Stallion. The novel by Walter Farley was serviceable. Written when Farley was in high school and college, it’s a standard boy’s adventure with ordinary prose and better-than-average horsemanship.

In contrast, Carroll Ballard’s movie looks gorgeous, thanks to Ballard and cinematographer Caleb Deschanel. The plot is pretty much the same, and very basic it is. But there are real feelings of loss and risk, giving the triumphal story more layers. And the performances by Kelly Reno, Mickey Rooney, Teri Garr, and Hoyt Axton are wonderfully natural.


Sam said...

I say, Babe, hands down.

Another favorite, is That Darn Cat.

And I was rather a fan of Harriet the Spy, although I know some people consider it a travesty.

J. L. Bell said...

Babe is excellent, but I think Dick King-Smith’s book is better to start from. Some people think George Miller's Babe: Pig in the City is even better, but I haven’t seen it.

Never sat through That Darn Cat, but I'll keep my eyes open. I did see Harriet the Spy and read the book, but both long past the age when they might speak to me; I didn’t really sense much in common between them.